Countries with highest paternity fraud rates – Global Statistics explained

• Posted on August 21, 2025August 21, 2025
• by Nana Kwesi Coomson
• Comment

Paternity fraud, sometimes referred to as misattributed paternity, occurs when a man is incorrectly identified as the biological father of a child. Although it is a global issue, the extent to which it occurs varies significantly from one country to another.

These variations not only reflect cultural and societal dynamics but also reveal how access to DNA testing and legal frameworks shape the discovery of such cases.

These Four Countries Have the Highest Paternity Fraud Rates

1. Jamaica – 34.6%

According to ResearchGate, Jamaica has one of the highest reported paternity fraud rates in the world, estimated at 34.6%. This means more than one in three men tested are not the biological fathers of the children in question.

Experts attribute this high figure to cultural factors, economic hardship, and limited communication within relationships. The lack of routine DNA testing also means that many cases go undetected unless disputes arise.

2. Nigeria – 30%

Nigeria follows closely with an estimated rate of 30%, pointing to a persistent crisis that raises deep trust issues within families. Cultural expectations, financial dependency, and gender dynamics often play a role in women concealing the true biological fathers of their children.

An infamous example of the complexities surrounding paternity in Nigeria is the confession of Elizabeth Bwalya Mwewa, a Zambian nurse who admitted on her deathbed to swapping over 5,000 babies. While not strictly a case of paternity fraud, it illustrates how systemic and social issues can undermine parental certainty in parts of Africa.

3. Canada – 2.8%

Wikipedia’s statistics state that, in Canada, the rate drops sharply to 2.8%, highlighting the stark difference between developed and developing nations. This lower figure reflects stronger access to DNA testing, greater legal oversight, and cultural norms that discourage misrepresentation.

However, studies also show that when paternity is specifically contested, the rates of non-paternal events can spike significantly higher — sometimes up to 17%–20%.

4. United Kingdom – 1.6%

The United Kingdom records some of the lowest reported rates globally, at 1.6%. This equates to about one in every 50 fathers raising a child that is not biologically theirs. Researchers stress, however, that these figures are based on representative samples. In cases where paternity is disputed and testing is conducted, the numbers rise sharply, echoing the patterns seen in Canada and Mexico.

Why the Numbers Differ

The differences in statistics are not only cultural but also methodological. In many parts of the world, paternity testing is only sought in moments of dispute — such as divorce cases, custody battles, or inheritance claims.

Studies show that when paternity is questioned, the rates of misattributed paternity can soar to between 17% and 33%, compared to 1%–5% in the general population.

The Role of DNA Testing

The rise of direct-to-consumer (DTC) DNA testing has revolutionised how families confront the question of paternity. More than 30 million people worldwide have used such services, and estimates suggest 1%–5% discover unexpected results, including misattributed paternity.

This technology is particularly common in developed nations, where testing is affordable and accessible. In regions like Nigeria, however, DNA testing remains limited, meaning many cases are likely hidden.

Paternity fraud is a deeply sensitive issue, with implications ranging from family trust to inheritance disputes. While the highest reported rates are found in countries like Jamaica (34.6%) and Nigeria (30%), nations such as the United Kingdom (1.6%) and Canada (2.8%) report far lower levels. These discrepancies underline how cultural attitudes, economic realities, and access to DNA testing all influence the visibility and frequency of paternity fraud.

As DNA testing becomes more widespread globally, more hidden cases are likely to emerge, reshaping conversations about trust, parenthood, and family stability.